The Trial Lawyer's Journal

TLJ Small Logo
Close
Group 39053677

Share Your Story with Trial Lawyer’s Journal

Trial Lawyer’s Journal is built on the voices of trial lawyers like you. Share your journey, insights, and experiences through articles, interviews, and our podcast, Celebrating Justice.

Stay Updated

Sign up for our newsletter to get the latest from TLJ.



    What Is an At-Fault Driver?

    An at-fault driver is a motorist who is legally responsible for causing an accident due to negligence, reckless behavior, or violation of traffic laws. Being deemed at fault can impact insurance claims, liability, and legal consequences.

    How is fault determined in an accident?

    Fault in an accident is determined through evidence, police reports, witness statements, and insurance investigations. Each state follows either an at-fault or no-fault insurance system, affecting how claims are handled.

    • Police reports and traffic citations can indicate fault.
    • Insurance companies analyze accident details to assign liability.
    • Comparative and contributory negligence laws vary by state.
    • Dashcam footage and witness testimony can influence fault determination.

    What happens if you are the at-fault driver?

    Being the at-fault driver can have financial and legal consequences, depending on the severity of the accident and state laws.

    • Insurance premiums may increase – At-fault drivers often see rate hikes.
    • Liability for damages – Responsible for covering victim’s damages and medical expenses.
    • Legal consequences – Severe cases may lead to lawsuits or criminal charges.
    • Impact on future claims – Multiple at-fault accidents can affect coverage eligibility.

    Can an at-fault driver recover compensation?

    Depending on the state’s negligence laws, an at-fault driver may still recover partial compensation in an accident claim.

    • Pure comparative negligence states – At-fault drivers can recover reduced damages based on their percentage of fault.
    • Modified comparative negligence states – Recovery is barred if fault exceeds a certain percentage (usually 50-51%).
    • Contributory negligence states – Any fault prevents compensation recovery.
    • Insurance coverage options – Collision coverage may help cover damages to the at-fault driver’s vehicle.

    Conclusion

    An at-fault driver is responsible for causing an accident and may face financial, insurance, and legal consequences. Understanding how fault is determined and how it impacts claims can help drivers navigate accident liability.

    What is an at-fault driver?

    An at-fault driver is a motorist who is legally responsible for causing an accident due to negligence, reckless behavior, or violation of traffic laws. Being deemed at fault affects insurance claims, liability, and potential legal consequences. Depending on the state’s laws, the at-fault driver may be required to compensate victims for damages and medical expenses.

    Insurance companies determine fault by reviewing police reports, witness statements, vehicle damage, and traffic laws. Adjusters analyze accident details, consider dashcam footage or surveillance videos, and apply state-specific negligence laws. Some states follow a no-fault system, where each driver’s insurer covers their own damages, while others assign fault to determine liability.

    Yes, an at-fault driver can dispute liability if they believe the fault assessment was incorrect. This can be done by:

    • Providing new evidence, such as photos, videos, or additional witness statements.
    • Requesting a review if the insurance company misinterpreted facts.

    Hiring an attorney to challenge the decision in court if necessary.
    Disputing fault is especially important in comparative negligence states, where reducing fault percentage can impact compensation.

    Yes, at-fault accidents typically result in higher insurance premiums, with rate increases lasting 3–5 years depending on the insurer and severity of the accident. Some insurance companies offer accident forgiveness for first-time offenders, but repeated at-fault accidents can lead to policy cancellations or non-renewals.

    Featured Articles

    Explore our Contributors

    Steven R. Young

    Trial Lawyer

    Law Offices of Steven R. Young

    Brewster Rawls

    Founder

    The Rawls Law Group

    Michael Abdan

    Partner

    CloudLex

    Chad Sands

    VP, Markeitng & Editor

    CloudLex, Trial Lawyer's Journal

    Michael Harris

    Partner

    Jordan Law

    Daniel Kaufman

    Artist

    Daniel Kaufman Artist

    Hunter J. Shkolnik

    Partner

    Napoli Shkolnik

    Stacy Brown Randall

    Author and Referral Coach

    Stacy Brown Randall

    Discover Next

    Insights from Experts

    Learn from industry experts about key cases, the business of law, and more insights that shape the future of trial law.

    Author